Let's Review...

Welcome to my blog! Here you will find archives of my reviews and interviews written for newmysteryreader.com, along with original stuff. It's here so YOU can comment on it.

Monday, January 04, 2010

The Lineup--anthology edited by Otto Penzler


Otto Penzler leads the life to which we should all aspire.

He owns the signature indie crime fiction bookstore in the US, Mysterious Bookshop. He’s got about a million of his own publishing imprints. He’s written his own books, and, specific to the purpose of this review, he edits the absolute coolest anthologies in the genre. He is one of the main reasons an “enthusiast press” exists for mystery fiction, and for that alone, we love the guy.

But don’t take our word for it. We asked Robert Crais for a few words about Penzler, and this was his response:

Otto Penzler is a national treasure. He is the creator and owner of the best known mystery bookstore on the planet, the Mysterious Bookshop. He created and founded Mysterious Press, is both a publisher and an editor, and is responsible for books published around the world. He is the world’s accepted authority on mystery fiction, and owns what is acknowledged to be the finest collection of first edition crime fiction on Earth. No one else could have assembled The Lineup. Writers of this caliber would never have written these essays for the money or exposure—none of us NEED the money or exposure—and had anyone else proposed the collection, I’m sure most of us would have passed (I would have). But Otto isn’t ‘anyone else.’ Otto is a great guy, a better friend, and a champion of the genre. I wrote my own piece because of my respect and love for the man.

His latest anthology is indeed titled The Lineup, and it adds much to his cred. It’s a highly entertaining and informative collection of essays by the leading series authors in crime fiction, talking the how’s and why’s behind their characters’ creation.

As you would expect, each author takes their own path, and the results are huge fun to read. Like most people, you will surely focus on the characters you are familiar with. After that, however, keep poking around, as you will find insight into characters that will certainly spark your interest towards checking out new works by authors you might not have considered reading.

Robert B. Parker delivers a Spenser short story. Spens and Susan are interviewed by an author who is profiling Real Men for a book. Spenser reluctantly talks about why he does what he does, with Susan’s cajoling. It’s full of Parker’s classic wit and snappy banter, and will help complete the circle for many Parker-philes.

Crais’ afore-mentioned contribution comes in two parts. First, an interview between author and character. Crais and Cole are taking a hike on Mt. Lee, where the Hollywood sign looks over the vast expanse of the author’s beloved L.A. Cole is a little cranky with the author as he talks about himself and Joe Pike (who is quickly becoming the dominant character in Crais’ universe). The author follows this with a more conventional essay about Pike specifically, and it’s actually much more informative if what you seek is the germ of the idea evolving into Elvis and Joe.

Authors like Michael Connelly (Harry Bosch) and Lee Child (Jack Reacher), present their information more journalistically, telling the basic story from their own point of view. Colin Dexter interviews himself about Inspector Morse. Ridley Pearson interrogates Lou Boldt. Jeffrey Deaver eulogizes Lincoln Rhyme.

The funniest—surprising to no one that is familiar with her books—is Laura Lipppman’s Tess Monaghan interview. Lippman brings all her wit and precision to bear in what is, of course, an exercise in navel-gazing. One character refers to another as a “fatless wench”. Gotta love that.
One of the more informative, from a “process” perspective, comes from David Morrell, telling the story of how Rambo was created, and the path it took to cinema immortality. Published years before the movie was made, First Blood was used by Stephen King (along with Double Indemnity), as a text in his creative writing class. It was, in its early stage, being set up for Steve McQueen. Morrell does a great job of shedding light on the life of a book and a character on the road to publication and, by extension, cinematic release.

All in all, the collection is a must-have for anyone that’s serious about their crime fiction, and another notch on the belt of Otto Penzler’s endlessly valuable contributions to the genre.